Friday, December 18, 2009

Filler Super Fillers

There was lots of discussion about a year ago about "Super Fillers".  Defined as "a game that fits inside 60 minutes with as meaty of experience as possible"

Well, last night we got some "Filler Super Fillers" which would be to me: "a game that fits inside 20 minutes with as meaty of experience as possible".

What did we play?

Ra: The Dice Game

Plays in 20 minutes tops with 2-plays.  Also does it very well.  I may still lean towards Roll Through the Ages, but I think there's plenty of room for both in my collection.  I at least want to come back and keep playing it.

Last night I finally started to analyze my decisions on a "points / die" basis.  You come up with some cool trade offs.  I'm sure Knizia meant for all of that to happen.

For example, the first Civilization you get is 5 points for 3 dice.  A 4th dice for a 2nd civilization is 0 points, but does enable you do get back to 5 for 3 or 10 for 4 the next time around.  Of course, you also have to value taking up 2 slots on the civilization track to bump your opponent.

3 Suns is just 3 points, which really isn't super efficient.

The river is lotsa cool.  Each river *could* be 3 points, but you also have to get it flooded with takes 3 dice for no points.

Anyway, it's a lot of fun little trade offs in the details.


Fairy Tale

Broke out the replacement copy my secret santa sent me.  Super awesome!

We played our standard 2-player variant.  Deal SEVEN cards per player.  For the first 2 rounds of drafting, draft 1 card and trash 1 card from the hand.  This gives the players more cards to peruse.  Since in a 3+ player game you see far more unique cards than in a 2-player game.

How did I do?  My wife schooled me.  Of course, she played a "Hunt All Evil" thinking it flipper her evil cards.  Actually, no, it left them alone but killed a critical "Unflip 2" card I had just played that turn.  Doh!

This is just an excellent little card game.  Sometimes I think I would like it to last a little longer, but then I just shrug and deal a new game.

Wednesday, December 16, 2009

2-Player Zendo Continued

I never really concluded my last post and Seth brought up some good ideas in the comments, so I thought I'd just keep rambling on the subject.

First of all, yes, the 3d6 was intended to be hidden from the student.  The complete rules of the variant proposed by "Adam McD" were originally posted here:

http://www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/58349/2-player-variant

And he had something similar to "if the student fails too much then both players lose".

I just don't like that rule though.  I mean, when playing with my wife it would work just fine since we're both primarily focused on having a good time, not on winning.


Hrm, so the biggest issue is giving the student too much incentive to just give up and make stupid guesses.  That means we should really weight him towards wanting to get done early.  How about this:

If student gets it in:
#Koans < (Target - 2):  Student gets 4 points
#Koans Within Target ± 2: master gets 1 point
#Koans = Target: Master 1 more point (2 total)
#Koans > (Target + 2): Student gets 1 point

That should really push the student to *want* to guess it quickly.  I still worry that if the 3d6 was actually ~16 then the student would stop having a reason to try and just shoot for the bomb to get 1 point.

Or conversely, once you have the lead, why not just bomb every student and master.  You can obviously bomb as a student, and you can make an insanely arcane rule to bomb as the master.


Hrm, or how about just say screw it.  If a student bombs it, declare that round null and immediately play another round with the same roles.  Of course, as soon as the student has made ~8 guesses they would probably just intentionally bomb instead of trying to answer.


Maybe the glitch should be determining who was doing the bombing.  Was it the master or the student?  I can't really lay the blame based on who is leading, because then the loser would have incentive to bomb it just as much as the leader.

The only other source of information is the balance of true and false Koans at the point of bombing.  Is there reason to believe that a balance of true and false is indicative of an easier or harder rule?  I think I may be on to something here.  But which way?  Is it easier to have a single case to compare against many?  Or is it easier to have many cases to compare against many cases?  I'll have to research this some and revisit it friday.

(I asked about rule easy/hard and balanced true/false over on bgg here:
http://www.boardgamegeek.com/article/4357597
)

Tuesday, December 15, 2009

2-Player Zendo

Well here's just a mess.  I need me a Zendo fix, but mostly I play 2-player.  And are there any good 2-player variants?  It doesn't really appear so.

It was hard as heck to find Kory Heath's official variant.  And after finding it... I'm horribly unimpressed.  It basically boils down to:

Each player simultaneously plays the student and the master.  All Koans are marked twice.  The marking on your side is correspondent to your rule.  The first player to guess the other's rule is the winner.

Now that's just horrible from a game theory stand point.  Make the hardest rule you can imagine and win.  Zendo for me isn't about making the hardest rule possible.  Instead, it's about helping the Students have a good time and make those leaps of intuition.


Another variant posted on the forums is at least more promising:

Take turns being student/master.  Master secretly rolls 3d6.  Master chooses rule that should take student the number of Koans equal to the result of the roll.

If the student gets the rule in less Koans, they earn the difference.  If they fail then they earn nothing *and* the master loses 3 points.

So it seems good in some ways.  You will have varying difficulty rules.  The master has reason to try and hit the target.

I just think it breaks down when the student has already built around 10 Koans.  At that point, isn't it just safer to intentionally be wrong and give the master -3 points?


So, I shall try to formulate some new variant here.  And it might be harder than I think.

Let's start with the promising bit of the 2nd variant.  Take turns being master and have a target number of Koans = 3d6.  Then what do we want to have the scoring do:

1. The student should *always* want to guess the rule as quickly as possible.
2. The master should want the student to take exactly 3d6 koans.

The issue arises that for the student to want to guess quickly, their reward relative to the masters should always be declining.

But at the same time, if the master is always gaining in potential for a new Koan then they will always want the student to keep building new Koans indefinitely.

Gah, I've wasted 10 minutes coming up with ideas and failing.  I shall revisit this again later.  Unless someone out there has a brilliant breakthru!

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Wood for (Video) Games

Just took delivery of the second guitar for the new PS3 rock band setup yesterday.  What kind did I snag?  A friggin' Rock Axe!  I didn't buy it from Amazon though, I don't think it's worth that much of a premium.

Why did I buy it?  Because it's a friggin' guitar with little game controller bits added in.  It's huge compared to the other controllers, but it feels nice and powerful.

Now, out of the box the actual fret buttons were supposed to be crap.  To fix that, I went ahead and shimmed them like in this HOWTO.  My wife obviously thought I was crazy for buying a controller that was humongous and had to be fixed before you could even use it.  I just thought I was being geeky.

How did it play in the end?  Very very nice.  The strum bar in particular is of very high quality.  I wouldn't recommend spending more than $30 on one, but if you can find it for that price again it can be worth it.



On a funny side note.  I know board game Prototypes don't need to be fancy.  But I've just found the fun of Windows ASCII codes with the ALT button: http://usefulshortcuts.com/alt-codes

Part of me wants to go and replace:

4VP if 5+ Red


into

5+ Red → 4☻


Just because it looks cooler :)

Monday, December 7, 2009

Ghosts in the Rules

Played a little Rook last night.  The whole concept of Rook gives me the giggles for the most part.  It's a deck of cards, with all the faces removed, so some religious nut can go to bed at night and not feel guilty for playing cards.

Now, I realize these days it has actually evolved past that.  But that was the original purpose of the game.  I'm also annoying that they left in "Aces are high" since when removing the face cards they mapped the face cards to "1".  Riiight.

It got me to thinking about other card games with oddball rules left over.  I think my most recent example was refreshing myself with house rules for Double Sheepshead.  I haven't played this since an exchange student in high school taught it to us.  Here are some of the oddballs:

1. If you capture an Ace♦ played by your opponents, score a point.  (Doesn't sound odd until you learn you don't actually know who your opponents are until they are revealed at some unknown point in time.)

2. If you capture the last trick with a Jack♣, score a point.

3. If you capture an opponent's Jack♣ on the last trick, score a point.  (I actually think the above two rules are pretty cute.  But really, who thought them up?)

4. If you win a trick worth 40+ value, score a point.  (Basically has to be all aces and 10s.  Happens occasionally on an off-suit, but weird ass rule to have.)

5. 10♥ is highest trump, or not, depending on house rules.  (Very odd rule since the other option is for the 10♥ to just be an off suit)


Anyway, I'm always fascinated by history of card games.  I actually geeked out my hosts last night mentioning all the names of "Oh Hell" I could remember.

Friday, December 4, 2009

Rigged the PS3

All the boxes from black friday finally arrived.  What did I do?

1. Stripped the hard drive out of the new PS3.
2. Put in a new 500GB Western Digital.
3. Booted up the PS3 to learn there is no OS on the firmware.
4. Went and downloaded PS3 OS onto a flash drive.
5. Booted the PS3 and loaded the OS off the flash drive.
6. Setup an online Playstation account on my PC (Access to keyboard)
7. Tied my Visa to my Playstation account.
8. Slapped the old PS Hard Drive onto some rail adapters to get it to a 3.5" standard.
9. Dug through tons of cables in closet to find a SATA power adapter.
10. Slapped old PS Hard Drive into HTPC.
11. Spent some time finding SATA toggle in HTPC Bios.
12. Got the data Drive registered in HTPC, Double the drive space! Woohoo!
13. Back on PS3, go through LONG setup process.
14. Got correct audio/video settings out of PS3.
15. Get correct audio/video settings on Onkyo receiver
16. Get PS3 signed onto wireless network (Very easy)
17. Sign PS3 into prior created Playstation Network ID.
18. Unpackage Rock Band 2
19. Put in RB2 disk, go through auto-update.
20. Unpackage Guitar
21. Use Guitar to calibrate audio/video on RB2.
22. Fix RB2 audio output settings (Not Dolby Digital by default)
23. Test RB2, it rocks.
24. Open and load RB1.  Try to export songs, fail.
25. Go buy export key from Playstation Store (Use Visa tied to account automatically)
26. Get songs exporting.
27. Cook dinner.
28. Tack out RB1, never touch it again.
29. Put back in RB2, test buying a song.  Works great.
30. Put together drums and test them, flawless.
31. Play some songs with the Missus when she got home.


Wheh!  That only took about 2.5 hours :)

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Jambo - Check

So I got another "long unplayed" checked off yesterday: Jambo.

How has it aged?  Very well thank you.  It was still a very close fought battle.  I pulled over the finish line at 62.  But then my wife unloaded 5 goods in her last turn to match me and take the win.  Good stuff.


I currently have the first expansion of Jambo.  We sort of played with it last night.  What do I mean sort of?  Well, there's a lot of bits to it:

New People / Artifacts / Animals - We definitely use these.  However, there are no new Wares, so to play the expansion you actually need to remove similar cards to keep the ratio the same.  The author actually has some suggestions as to what he likes to remove, and we stick fairly close to this.

Huts/Relics - Never tried them.  Add new mechanics I'm not really looking for.


So there's another expansion out now.  Do I snag it?  It's cheap enough.  And I have played Jambo 10 times now and don't think that number will stop.  But what does the next expansion offer?  Some cool new Ware cards that feature new combos and some "wild" goods.  But if I include those, then I have to include all the cards I got to remove when adding the first expansion.  And some of those cards removed were ones my wife and I just did not enjoy.

Surprisingly, it wasn't the "take-that" animal cards that we wanted removed.  It was the odd-ball auction cards that caused a large hiccup in gameplay.  My wife just doesn't like auction games hardly at all, and tossing small-scale auctions into a 2-player economic card game was not her idea of fun.

Sooo.... will I get the 2nd expansion?  Maybe.  If I see it in my FLGS I'll probably cave.